Opportunistic abuse

BOGO abuse

BOGO abuse

BOGO abuse

Returning the full-price item from a buy-one-get-one or buy-more-save-more deal and keeping the discounted one.

How it works
  1. 01Deal appliedBuy one, get one, or buy more, save more.
  2. 02Discount spreadThe discount is applied across the items in the order.
  3. 03Full-price item returnedThe customer returns the item refunded at full price.
  4. 04Discounted item keptThey keep the item that was cheap or free.
  5. 05Margin lostYou refunded more than the customer effectively paid.
Warning signs
  • Partial returns on BOGO or bundle orders
  • Refunds that exceed the item's effective paid price
  • The same customer repeating the pattern across promotions
  • Bundles where the higher-priced item is always the one returned

What is BOGO abuse?

BOGO abuse is using a buy-one-get-one or tiered discount, then returning the full-price item and keeping the discounted or free one. If the refund doesn’t account for the deal, the customer ends up paying far less than the promotion intended.

It’s usually a loophole in how returns are calculated rather than fraud. Most of it is closed by refunding the price actually paid.

Who it hits

Apparel, beauty, footwear and any brand that runs BOGO, bundle or spend-more-save-more promotions.

What it costs

The gap between the full-price refund and what the customer actually paid, plus the cost of the return itself.

How to prevent it

  • Refund the price paid after the promotion is allocated across the order.

  • State in your promo terms how partial returns are refunded.

  • Flag customers who repeatedly return the higher-priced item from promotions.

FAQ

Is BOGO abuse fraud?

Usually not. It exploits how refunds are calculated. Fixing the calculation removes most of it.

What’s the fairest way to refund a partial return?

Allocate the discount across all items in the deal and refund only the returned item’s share.

How Pinch stops it

Return Abuse →

Free lookback · for qualified brands

See what you lost last year. Free.

01

Share 12 months of data.

Install the Shopify app or SFCC cartridge, or send order, return and claim exports.

02

Get your lookback in under two weeks.

What you lost to return and claims abuse, and who took it.

03

Qualified brands try Pinch free for three months.

Run it on live orders, then decide.